Ethnography of a political ritual: Speeches given to new Swiss citizens by representatives of the state
Ossipow, L. & Felder, M. · Citizenship Studies (2015) · DOI: 10.1080/13621025.2015.1006175
In short
In Geneva, becoming Swiss ends with a ceremony where new citizens take an oath and listen to a speech by a member of the cantonal government. This article analyses these speeches to understand what, in the eyes of the state, turns a foreigner into a member of the national and, above all, the cantonal community. Comparing the speeches of three successive magistrates between 2008 and 2012, it shows that the conception of nationality shifted from an assimilationist view, based on feelings of belonging, to a view centred on rights and duties, even though the law had not changed and regardless of the magistrates' party affiliation.
Research question
What conceptions of the state, the nation and nationality do official speeches at naturalisation ceremonies convey? What change, if any, does this rite of passage acknowledge in the people being naturalised?
Data and methods
Ethnographic research on naturalisation in Geneva conducted between 2008 and 2013, extending an earlier study that ended in 1991.
Observation of five naturalisation ceremonies presided over by three magistrates (2008, 2012), informal conversations with new citizens and authorities, and analysis of the oath and of the speeches.
Part of a broader study of the naturalisation process, including observation of interviews between civil servants and candidates.
Funded by the Centre d'études de la diversité culturelle et de la citoyenneté, Geneva.
Key findings
The ceremony works as a political ritual. Waiting rooms, protocol and moments of silence mark a liminal phase. The only choice left to the candidates is whether to "swear" or "promise" in the oath.
The oath emphasises the canton and ongoing proof. New citizens pledge loyalty to the Republic and canton of Geneva as well as to the Confederation, and undertake to justify their membership "by their actions and behaviour": naturalisation is framed as an everyday commitment rather than a one-off decision.
From feelings to rights. In 2008, the magistrate described new citizens as transformed over time, sharing the same intimate patriotic attachment as native Swiss, which is why they deserved naturalisation. By 2012, his successor thanked them for choosing naturalisation and defined being Swiss as being "endowed with all of the rights of a citizen": a matter of shared democratic values and respect for the constitution, not of identity.
No automatic link between law and discourse. This shift happened without any change in nationality law, and it does not follow party lines. It reflects the magistrates' personal backgrounds and Geneva's political context, where voters rejected the national-conservative popular initiatives adopted elsewhere in Switzerland.
Contribution
The article questions attempts to classify countries by a single, coherent conception of nationality, such as the ethnic–civic dichotomy, a debate in which Switzerland has been used to support opposing theses. It shows that official discourse covers a broad and changing range of conceptions of the state and citizenship. The authors argue that ceremony speeches are less the expression of an ideological framework than an opportunity to push back against a public discourse perceived as threatening, addressed to new citizens but also to voters tempted by nationalist parties.
Key concepts
naturalisation · nationality · citizenship ceremonies · political ritual · rite of passage · oath of allegiance · cantonal citizenship · assimilation
How to cite
Ossipow, L. & Felder, M. (2015). Ethnography of a political ritual: Speeches given to new Swiss citizens by representatives of the state. Citizenship Studies, 19(3–4), 233–247. https://doi.org/10.1080/13621025.2015.1006175