Social workers and irregular migrants in the assistance circuit: making sense of paradoxical inclusion
Felder, M., Fneich, S. & Stavo-Debauge, J. · Social Inclusion (2023) · DOI: 10.17645/si.v11i3.6764
In short
Despite restrictive national policies, cities sometimes support irregular migrants. Research usually looks at this through policies and the tension between inclusive local actors and exclusionary national authorities. This article shifts the focus to the street level. Following young North African men without papers in Geneva, it describes the "assistance circuit": a daily routine dictated by services offered at fixed times in scattered places. It shows how social workers make sense of this work, and why the resulting inclusion is paradoxical.
Research question
How is support to irregular migrants delivered and experienced at street level, and how do frontline social workers make sense of their work?
Data and methods
Ethnographic study of precarious newcomers in Geneva, Switzerland, focusing on young North African men without legal status.
Interviews and observations with the newcomers and with social workers in low-threshold reception services.
Part of a broader SNSF project on the (in)hospitality of European cities towards precarious newcomers.
Key findings
At first, the young men find the assistance in Geneva generous. Over time, following the circuit of meals, showers and shelters becomes exhausting, and they develop a sense of entrapment and alienation, along with escape strategies.
Access is theoretically unconditional, but in practice it requires the ability to move around, keep to schedules and hold the pace over time. Help is never guaranteed: places close at certain times, and scarce resources go first-come, first-served.
The constraints reflect a social work paradigm that keeps people on the move, limits dependency and promotes autonomy.
This coexists with a competing "palliative" paradigm focused on survival and dignity, which seems just as paradoxical to migrants who aspire to work and full participation.
Their inclusion is also shaped by characteristics beyond legal status: stigmatisation, little support from settled compatriots and the criminal behaviour of some.
Contribution
The article complements policy-centred approaches by showing that the limits of inclusion do not only stem from restrictive migration law. They also stem from the practical and symbolic organisation of assistance itself. It calls for more attention to the heterogeneity of the category "irregular migrants" and to the temporal and practical side of inclusion.
Key concepts
assistance circuit · paradoxical inclusion · street-level social work · low-threshold services · autonomy · palliative assistance · irregular migrants
How to cite
Felder, M., Fneich, S. & Stavo-Debauge, J. (2023). Social workers and irregular migrants in the assistance circuit: making sense of paradoxical inclusion. Social Inclusion, 11(3), 116–127. https://doi.org/10.17645/si.v11i3.6764