Shops as the bricks and mortar of place identity. A comparison of shopping streets in Brussels, Paris and Geneva
Felder, M. & Pignolo, L. · In Ferro, L. et al. (eds), Moving Cities – Contested Views on Urban Life. Wiesbaden: Springer VS (2018) · DOI: 10.1007/978-3-658-18462-9_7
In short
Cities and neighbourhoods are often seen through their main street, and more specifically through its shops. This chapter argues that shops are the "bricks and mortar" of place identity. Comparing shopping streets in Brussels, Paris and Geneva, it shows that shops shape who feels welcome on a street, that people use them to tell stories about what a place is or is becoming, and that, as material entities, they allow some interpretations and resist others.
Research question
How do shops contribute to the negotiation and manufacturing of place identities? Are they only means through which owners shape the streetscape and others voice competing narratives, or can they act as non-human actors that transform meaning rather than merely carry it?
Data and methods
Comparative study of three shopping streets: Rue du Fort in Saint-Gilles (Brussels), Rue Dénoyez in Belleville (Paris) and Boulevard Carl-Vogt in La Jonction (Geneva).
Observations and 45 interviews with shop owners, clerks and users of the three streets.
Key findings
Shop owners are key actors in the symbolic struggle over place identity. Their choices of name, signs, furniture, products, opening hours and prices shape the street's appearance and signal who belongs and who is "out of place". As one shop owner put it, shop windows are "the neighbourhood's showcase".
The same shop can carry opposite meanings. An organic grocery in Saint-Gilles embodies the revival of a traditional shopping street for some, and gentrification and exclusion for poorer residents who feel judged and find it too expensive. A café-library in Belleville echoes the area's bohemian past for some, and clashes with its working-class history for others.
Shops are read as signs of continuity or change, judged positively or negatively. This gives four kinds of narrative: authenticity, improvement, dullness and loss of authenticity. Cultural and economic capital shapes which one people adopt.
In La Jonction, by contrast, interviewees pointed to several businesses, none of them contested: each clearly signalled either continuity (a grocery) or change (a new frozen yogurt shop or pizzeria), and people picked the ones that fitted their narrative.
Not all shops weigh equally. A few highly symbolic businesses concentrate the debate, and people's own commercial or affective ties to "their" grocery or bakery matter too.
Contribution
The chapter brings together political economy and symbolic economy perspectives on commercial streets. It shows why place identities are neither fixed nor endlessly fluid: narratives about a place differ by social position, but they rest on a material base, bricks-and-mortar businesses, which gives them a certain coherence and stability.
Key concepts
place identity · sense of place · commercial streets · shops as non-human actors · authenticity · gentrification · symbolic economy
How to cite
Felder, M. & Pignolo, L. (2018). Shops as the bricks and mortar of place identity. A comparison of shopping streets in Brussels, Paris and Geneva. In Ferro, L. et al. (eds), Moving Cities – Contested Views on Urban Life. Wiesbaden: Springer VS, 97–114. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-658-18462-9_7