Acquaintances or familiar strangers? How similarity and spatial proximity shape neighbour relations within residential buildings
Felder, M., Favre, G., Tulin, M. & Koutsolampros, P. · Housing, Theory and Society (2023) · DOI: 10.1080/14036096.2023.2247404
In short
City dwellers choose their friends by social similarity, but who they greet, chat with and exchange favours with in their building depends a lot on where neighbours live. This article compares the roles of spatial proximity and social similarity in neighbour relations, using network data from four apartment buildings in Geneva. It also breaks new ground by comparing two kinds of ties: weak ties, between people who interact regularly, and "invisible ties" to familiar strangers.
Research question
How do spatial proximity within a building and social similarity between households shape who becomes an acquaintance, who remains a familiar stranger, and who stays a complete stranger?
Data and methods
Four social network datasets describing relations among households in four rented apartment buildings in Geneva, Switzerland.
A measure of spatial distance that accounts for how the layout and materiality of buildings shape relations through accessibility, visibility and audibility.
Logistic regressions with QAP tests, combined in a meta-analysis across the four buildings.
Key findings
Spatial proximity increases the likelihood of weak ties: the neighbour you hear through the wall is not the same as the one three floors up.
Compared with sociability, familiarity depends less on individual characteristics and similarity. Familiar strangers are close enough to be visible, but they are not the closest neighbours, who are more likely to be acquaintances.
The youngest residents are less likely to be familiar strangers to others. Long-term residents maintain invisible ties that never develop into weak ties, suggesting a commitment to keep one's distance.
Anonymity is a constitutive dimension of neighbouring, even in modest buildings: parts of one's "own" building remain terra incognita.
Proximity is not only physical: doors, walls, floors, pipes and ventilation let gazes, sounds and smells travel, creating knowledge, judgement, empathy or conflict.
Contribution
The article avoids the dichotomy between sociability and anonymity by measuring familiarity as a network of invisible ties. It calls for more precision in talk of "local ties" and shows that sociability, familiarity and anonymity are all part of neighbouring, even at the scale of a single building.
Key concepts
spatial proximity · homophily · weak ties · invisible ties · familiar strangers · anonymity · building materiality · social network analysis
How to cite
Felder, M., Favre, G., Tulin, M. & Koutsolampros, P. (2023). Acquaintances or familiar strangers? How similarity and spatial proximity shape neighbour relations within residential buildings. Housing, Theory and Society, 40(5), 642–659. https://doi.org/10.1080/14036096.2023.2247404