Between Hospitality and Inhospitality: The Janus-faced ‘Arrival Infrastructure’
Felder, M., Stavo-Debauge, J., Pattaroni, L., Trossat, M. & Drevon, G. · Urban Planning (2020) · DOI: 10.17645/up.v5i3.2941
In short
Shelters, soup kitchens, day centres and other services form the "arrival infrastructure" that migrants rely on when they reach a new city. The concept usually carries positive connotations. Comparing newcomers' experiences in Brussels and Geneva, this article shows that arrival infrastructure is Janus-faced: it welcomes newcomers, but it also rejects, deceives and disappoints them, forcing them to keep moving to meet their needs. The article proposes the notion of a "hospitable milieu" to capture what makes a city welcoming beyond its infrastructure.
Research question
Is arrival infrastructure sufficient to make a city hospitable to precarious newcomers? In what ways can it also be inhospitable?
Data and methods
Ethnographic research and interviews with 49 migrants who had arrived in Brussels or Geneva no more than about six months earlier.
Attention not only to where they slept but to where they spent their days and what they did.
Part of the SNSF project "Urban Hospitality: What Place for Precarious Newcomers in European Cities".
Key findings
Arrival infrastructure is inhospitable in four ways, paradoxically linked to features meant to stabilise its capacity to receive:
Limitations and shortcomings of duration, space and amenities, for instance night shelters that limit consecutive nights and close during the day.
Trials or tests newcomers must overcome to access it: finding information, locating places, filling in forms, overcoming stigma.
Forms of closure needed to protect the most vulnerable: infrastructure open to everyone can fail to offer a protective shield.
Divergent conceptions of hospitality among those who run it, ranging from non-interference to more active engagement.
The wider urban environment also matters: price levels, openness of labour and housing markets, and how public space treats people depending on gender, race, appearance and legal status. Some newcomers in Brussels did not aim to settle at all but saw the city as a stopover.
Contribution
The article embeds arrival infrastructure in the broader, ambiguous history of the management of poor and mobile populations, between compassion and repression. The notion of milieu, emerging from the transaction between an environment and a person's aspirations, skills and resources, challenges the idea that a city's hospitality can be assessed in advance from its infrastructure. A hospitable milieu is one that invites the newcomer to stay.
Key concepts
arrival infrastructure · hospitality · inhospitality · hospitable milieu · trials · grammars of hospitality · newcomers
How to cite
Felder, M., Stavo-Debauge, J., Pattaroni, L., Trossat, M. & Drevon, G. (2020). Between Hospitality and Inhospitality: The Janus-faced ‘Arrival Infrastructure’. Urban Planning, 5(3), 55–66. https://doi.org/10.17645/up.v5i3.2941