Familiarity as a practical sense of place
Felder, M. · Sociological Theory (2021) · DOI: 10.1177/07352751211037724
In short
"Familiar" can mean what we know intimately or what we merely recognise from having seen it before. This theoretical article argues that this is not a contradiction: familiarity combines both. It proposes to understand familiarity as a practical sense of place, a relationship to people and places that develops over time and through experience, and that lets us progressively stop paying attention to what appears "usual". Familiarity is not only an individual, cognitive matter: it is an ongoing relational and collective achievement, which allows city dwellers to go about their daily lives in places that could otherwise seem anonymous.
Research question
How can familiarity be conceptualised sociologically? The article unfolds five questions: What is familiarity? Where does it come from? What threatens it? What does it produce? How can it be operationalised and studied empirically?
Data and methods
A theoretical and conceptual article, drawing on phenomenology (Schütz, Heidegger), urban sociology and ethnographies of city life, notably Talja Blokland's work on "public familiarity", Goffman's civil inattention and research on familiar strangers.
Illustrated with interviews conducted in 2015–2016 with residents of four buildings in central Geneva, Switzerland, about their use and experience of the city, their neighbourhood and their neighbours.
Key findings
Two layers of knowledge. Familiarity rests on typification, recognising things as similar to what we know, and on first-hand knowledge that recognises specific people, places and situations as the same. As an embodied understanding, it cannot be reduced to a quantity of knowledge or placed on a scale from weak to strong attachment.
Familiarisation is a learning process that does not lead to ever deeper knowledge. Repetition and stable environments favour it, but routines do not guarantee it. Familiar strangers are known personally yet remain strangers: we recognise them without knowing much about them, and without wanting to.
Familiarity is collective. Feeling at ease somewhere depends on other people behaving routinely there. Being recognised matters as much as recognising: a new resident felt he belonged once the dealers in front of his building stopped calling out to him, because he had become familiar to them.
Familiarity is fragile. It can be disrupted by sudden events, but also by subtle changes such as the demolition of a building, the closure of a café or the disappearance of a familiar stranger, or by a changed perception of a place, as when one feels "out of place". Defamiliarisation can also start a new learning process.
Its effects are ambivalent. Familiarity provides ease, the ability to know what to expect and whom to trust or distrust, and can foster attachment and belonging. But being treated as a familiar stranger can signal recognition or contempt, depending on context and power relations, and "overfamiliarity" can turn into boredom or a sense of entrapment.
Studying it requires specific methods, since familiarity is largely tacit knowledge: elicitation techniques, diaries, walking methods, visual methods, and qualitative or statistical network analysis of familiar strangers.
Contribution
The article offers a processual and relational concept, familiarisation, defamiliarisation and refamiliarisation, to study how coexistence works in dense and diverse cities, beyond the opposition between the anonymous city and the urban village. It draws attention to what happens "in between", when people move through public space, and asks whether cities should be designed to support routine practices and fleeting encounters between familiar strangers.
Key concepts
familiarity · familiarisation · practical sense of place · familiar strangers · public familiarity · civil inattention · defamiliarisation · belonging
How to cite
Felder, M. (2021). Familiarity as a practical sense of place. Sociological Theory, 39(3), 180–199. https://doi.org/10.1177/07352751211037724